cat-users AT lists.geant.org
Subject: The mailing list for users of the eduroam Configuration Assistant Tool (CAT)
List archive
Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11
Chronological Thread
- From: <address@concealed>
- To: <address@concealed>
- Cc: <address@concealed>
- Subject: Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11
- Date: Mon, 26 Jan 2026 12:07:26 +0000
- Accept-language: en-US, de-CH, de-DE
- Arc-authentication-results: i=1; mx.microsoft.com 1; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=unibe.ch; dmarc=pass action=none header.from=unibe.ch; dkim=pass header.d=unibe.ch; arc=none
- Arc-message-signature: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=microsoft.com; s=arcselector10001; h=From:Date:Subject:Message-ID:Content-Type:MIME-Version:X-MS-Exchange-AntiSpam-MessageData-ChunkCount:X-MS-Exchange-AntiSpam-MessageData-0:X-MS-Exchange-AntiSpam-MessageData-1; bh=h2JkEpIrdMARtSwcilXwqduWmVGjl5tgNeBsxP6qeUQ=; b=ce8GUj8nA6qMPSBho6wQk8SyAcrF921xwTVJ24X/GF6Rl31vZyfgZ0HQNG2N/wsrjAiuvC0t2v7roio7RUK+woRlWZvXPipMvmrsNwpRrdPQrmhXiP5VTB4uWiIJU3HzRZYxpATusNmjYuJOH0eJfGBhP8NwAFt7MBJExGijugKErM9zKwZt7i4L8WRQrEGMt6z/xynnZJPkjDXJS7CvLkOGclLWPOMujneD8qpJAnY6YE2oH9+cxu2GNW95EzG/zhM8rAcV0oZTHJ4jxh8tjcV11u4rb7Tw04iMrF5ebfI8ONOugdmzhyr3iKxqUizYrVjKVWRfqFvlKK1robMvGw==
- Arc-seal: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; s=arcselector10001; d=microsoft.com; cv=none; b=Il+u0eKczpP1oDHUMJIC1QkvowNMrw0IrTvsc4FiAqaaYHwJTLhympJTLB7tiaPRGLZ+cM0OMG0p+l9leXY/mJaRLPprYQOeTrcBepdwPAiZk8XcfLP17pgLIpAmdLx34sIFkYEmSdfDs2itXbr1ixfOSNIaBqm57hCCWX0kJ00grLiXTY+/X/zCum2b9/ukue0JYo0xTqvmMLaKpX187S28hzU/U0Ggz9SbdzOV6HTEEla27xn6r0cCUZv7lLHQy0x+N9BqxU3s6sAr1cgrDSWknGg8DbYU9byFogK4LpHeJHafBXLNxJGRWhSukebpW+bjWontPcnRyh1DCaiUVg==
- Authentication-results: mail.geant.org; dkim=pass (2048-bit key; unprotected) header.d=unibe.ch address@concealed header.a=rsa-sha256 header.s=selector1 header.b=hdem3yPA; dkim-atps=neutral
- Authentication-results: dkim=none (message not signed) header.d=none;dmarc=none action=none header.from=unibe.ch;
Hi Martin
Thanks to you as well for the informative feedback!
> This is one more quirk of the Windows supplicant, surprisingly this adheres
> to some old PEAP variety. Windows will NOT allow you to pre-set a realm.
> You can only provide the username part of the outer identity. If the user
> is required to enter their username, the realm part will ALWAYS be what the
> user types after the '@'.
Good to know, did not know about it but makes "sense" __
> OTOH, you do want to make your anonymous outer id mandatory in the
> freeradius config, as this prevents clueless Android users/devices from
> naively typing in just the short, realm-less username (both inner and outer
> ID), along with specifying the weakest of certificate checks This would be
> "Accept all CAs present in system store" in most cases.
Indeed, but this is already given / mandatory by our FreeRADIUS configuration.
> A mandatory outer ID can be quite tedious for your Windows users though, as
> the USER must ALWAYS type in their realm correctly.
Those clients we talk about here are all corporate managed by our workplace /
client team; somehow they will need to figure out, how we can overcome those
user-based " obstacles". But I will work with them on this topic, I think it
should be somehow possible to set the predefined anonymous account to
anonymous@realm via GPO. But they know better than me.
I will go through the testing steps of Tomasz and will get back tot he
mailing list soon.
Best regards
Dominic
-
[[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11,
dominic.stalder, 01/23/2026
-
Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11,
Wenche Backman-Kamila, 01/26/2026
-
Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11,
dominic.stalder, 01/26/2026
-
Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11,
Tomasz Wolniewicz, 01/26/2026
-
Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11,
dominic.stalder, 01/26/2026
- Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11, Tomasz Wolniewicz, 01/26/2026
-
Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11,
dominic.stalder, 01/26/2026
-
Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11,
Tomasz Wolniewicz, 01/26/2026
-
Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11,
dominic.stalder, 01/26/2026
- <Possible follow-up(s)>
-
Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11,
Stefan Paetow, 01/23/2026
-
Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11,
dominic.stalder, 01/24/2026
-
Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11,
Martin Pauly, 01/26/2026
- Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11, dominic.stalder, 01/26/2026
-
Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11,
Martin Pauly, 01/26/2026
-
Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11,
dominic.stalder, 01/24/2026
-
Re: [[cat-users]] Question / SSID eduroam w/ and w/o CAT eduroam installer on Windows 11,
Wenche Backman-Kamila, 01/26/2026
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.19+.
