Subject: An open discussion list for topics related to the geteduroam service
List archive
Re: default/other languages instead of device language in new geteduroam android
Chronological Thread
- From: Paul Dekkers <paul.dekkers AT surf.nl>
- To: ALBRIZIO DANIELE <albrizio AT units.it>
- Cc: "geteduroam AT lists.geant.org" <geteduroam AT lists.geant.org>
- Subject: Re: default/other languages instead of device language in new geteduroam android
- Date: Fri, 5 Jan 2024 14:11:28 +0100
- Arc-authentication-results: i=1; mx.microsoft.com 1; spf=pass smtp.mailfrom=surf.nl; dmarc=pass action=none header.from=surf.nl; dkim=pass header.d=surf.nl; arc=none
- Arc-message-signature: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; c=relaxed/relaxed; d=microsoft.com; s=arcselector9901; h=From:Date:Subject:Message-ID:Content-Type:MIME-Version:X-MS-Exchange-AntiSpam-MessageData-ChunkCount:X-MS-Exchange-AntiSpam-MessageData-0:X-MS-Exchange-AntiSpam-MessageData-1; bh=5eRj/OqxED+TzQ8W3m2zGEZE7P6xJWb3iZfSQYpzaAQ=; b=b65wqwqo+VTgGPJdtBg9kwynKdGgY3C/VMYo12Mgh5aCrHOMwtns3JwtuV8a1Nl4ihL7X1PsRwa4dYqXurbw70lp8z6tDhD+C3/GxsiCrxn3yiJ7DgbDYCl/p9sz5eOxhWDpDQ40uvg2E17rlw7Oj1XKorkcqsJruW1TsxXHRrRaVeuGYF2BECscl1ebUCyImCQ/tL+80Kkgk0n/jmYjZhOTlg2GVmpVnbyT2+Kj79F1pnrAcHPfiyMiooBqxq2fuioKav6p/mZNPCx2gjCixNVZSHt+aL9CX0xzRSvtA5kIOMnZWIJvPvCIu/zz44/4BqRqdVIh5fG3hBX/ei9Tcw==
- Arc-seal: i=1; a=rsa-sha256; s=arcselector9901; d=microsoft.com; cv=none; b=ktY8MhFv9geq46xZ2OZNFod+0J08aUpJMhvyIaTx4kllggAfdLv7ya1IMHS+jwxSga4VGcLWasp9kQeQdOfA6iMLxv2Wmsp3lBMIIBipBMNXcow1LrjJ5ZhfW1+zf812+YXO58gtchuKFQ3ivDXStAwQZL86HkrfnznVKydkRa8eKKHmpdE7oQsD/nQuHR3IHVGj/K/va5nqwr6Tu/j/rcr7SOx12H6ubZ/bPCyHp3UT9gI39RkOwPOUfrSFMcXXYnvzbCvdjz/v9nhnJnFwGQzs0zehyV75VMumwHHceoqfe5U8G0argXsE9diJFMESjtahmG86g0zuRry4PGKw8w==
- Authentication-results: dkim=none (message not signed) header.d=none;dmarc=none action=none header.from=surf.nl;
- Autocrypt: addr=paul.dekkers AT surf.nl; keydata= xsDNBFzP6HIBDADK8Wn7ods1w4ysf5c/GeUkDm2doxOZRUU3ZSMM0aG9aN2jqpZB11xoTuAv k+J3kOpRY542rbHTxkbdiIYFiKS5ff9bAPfn1MUOy+XErLPUzZ/Z3GO6kCpTkcHYKVN2Iehd QCdn7UbNRRzygiVHiRWi8jkhutBWBHHy7hcVWXtHfxb5Ot7I6Z9F2Aso6sB543UrQVxEl0h1 AuNN2HXVW536LaGh+ZRTPPPj99nR8UvNnJ4Q/Jh9a6/C9TB1vGm/4oTWG2gnFcq9CBQB9+E0 GZ7S9ddyKzXE97wziJdhC4e14s9aSiG9Du98C62ilTzOk4muOV6XU0JZOy3jwIt6bS2m9zGf yUxhKs5mNwrCUeBqt5uKgUXAG0MnQ70lMmiGyMNwUkCXuHiScvzB7rdXM0h2pvfrMMsQ1BA5 +0Zb1hkkq5eYVUE+e9xJID82ShdMOTievgSdc4JP4lJuUAjVf30u5uUe/uxsDxc1zfnZsp30 ezTIhp2SxszZcWjzTnn7tSEAEQEAAc0jUGF1bCBEZWtrZXJzIDxwYXVsLmRla2tlcnNAc3Vy Zi5ubD7CwQ4EEwEIADgWIQQ3Xw/6ofYHVAb73o89O9GpKK14OgUCXM/ocgIbIwULCQgHAgYV CgkICwIEFgIDAQIeAQIXgAAKCRA9O9GpKK14OsHaDACFjL2wGvcSxecAVjShtnOwHgi5iO+r MUQiplP7/dD8awcBxuj1ihv/kZoatI0tSxsXs6OqYqG/ivJfCaXX51dYANDfDI4E8FLN+eCj v3ndVJHEWdixNrVH+sdS4itZt0omQ28dbMpJc7opOw42o5xMmypMMzo4enHZcaYr4fktAu5B 2E3eekw8aXOHPSrTmIAZjhaKCdZ5CtOotgoUGnrQbHIVlPh7PJBCUTlNXDynjLdznhYJjvBN GnT9B+PPfJ0TQMBv0gqWlfJA+GSKl//pz+Jqh1ByyRFXZaG0imE4eLaODSb+3aoD36pWMrdV 31m+qeEzB2V6I40vdBmZEtpX+01l3kuIPa/ZpJ3MCaeVlQ2ADkZwz1DVEV4aasOkKL2hAlMz bSChFnSA6OhOS+2L+7HAtI62OPj0VkXERqeFPpOWFG0OzqJUCBB5x/OdhoMiVjI2KNtMDxoD Y4L+u1MeNwm7fPYrdQn8aDN0Lc5tEdw29mwWwBLjiu+u8jCEyGnOwM0EXM/ocgEMALdymAvx UsfhoNnNR+SaJCUVwmBMjt9spGs1E27yqHMs7jDnZ87uh2B220GmZGKFkf4SbRHUJhPGX+rg Ez2vvlBwZonBKDY1SyCPRI6ffaivoz9hw+GXpQYQwIZ1gJWN7MvhzIbG+b+Y6pRMRsWSjThA ImieLS2+K2oR6XenxKG/dZg8qO/Uv5Qvb66rWtFM9D48iurcUu3ndotJPAkKetUg3dny4nzp D1wT26RcqEh8huJfZK8JdML+9Q1dHoMhtwRzTTWQ4rxwEr2X1ymaF4QaG8LbuT4/Owrp5vGd YI7Wh2Lwjwn6tJE715eePcoahQwgBBwsKBCkRDOQ3dA8bUO/G8p7SRTj/CAymx5unis3H6O/ jQmi3cgVLNg6CYwPGptFRrLxqT/eWsNy/2Dpd8VHajjVKQ6bC0MNz+lHoFkNMc/CaTY8BQix xM4mtm5rbbogX9pBPSUx5vVgd1Vbw8sQT2wFxUI3Q3r4KaKD5MVucDTg3OxcMNQxRTLDdonI owARAQABwsD2BBgBCAAgFiEEN18P+qH2B1QG+96PPTvRqSiteDoFAlzP6HICGwwACgkQPTvR qSiteDqo6gwAqIpD/D4lNkUehSf+U8l9lTpkWNAEfB9PgAMIFrFQ3YUuEmhFlv8uKi6Y7apX 89tmrVUgc5RLglf7e4geYv69wLY4R7jMIUs0g9cv/g71rhfszjDJGe/4ppa+qHTk69Uq556d B9nMtFF2YWvq77Y1WBKv/r3hmJLQYNZBaCBSPI9OpZ0UCw3hp0ip/LUejVXLRkU+ZAb6jeEt gd2zoIiXOHCazaGD6EGvLQxzuwPVPXPLU6kahtJoJAa/OOWyzSnd+Ipio6Vi6tdDVLEXbTVn AjnVOlEnGc6dhh1TOxPv/lHslYxfSTrCoBRIKcXS/5bkxvTOZpgSRyKsksh1fgD1IIPjLqs2 K7KOXgocNG+iIOMcLbSsp8R7GRUMmzeTIPHnW1xC9OIgU16KSxaDWa6tX6NOcY5iHRlRXw5Q 9WVGgnHIbfR/2hoyXzbVMzM2uiTEJ9qG4+GtMUBeLdEo8DsbX+QdP71NgcCcBUtUe9LfDEJ+ yZ0Nj/dbF6RX3MTEJRiy
Hi,
The discovery is still not multi-lingual, we're working on that. The issue is in part with performance, and meanwhile we stick to the "default" language.
For privacy considerations the processing of the discovery is
entirely done on the client.
The question is, should we send all languages to the client
(increasing the discovery file size!) and have the client decide
on the order; that means, if my language preference is NL-DE-EN I
would get NL for most institutions, but eg. DE for german
institutions that are very unlikely mine anyway: or is it OK to
stick to English for those, and choose an NL or IT file
server-side. (That would perform well, but we can't take the
language order into account. Unless we do more processing
server-side and use the entire order - but still not search. This
wouldn't work with our current CDN though.)
We have very poor performing Android phones in the community, think about African countries, and those need to keep up and process this information also. The current discovery is already a bit slow for some.
Either way, this behaviour has not changed in the past years.
In your case, it's different BTW from ours in the Netherlands, as we have no NL translation in CAT. That means we're assuming in the geteduroam discovery that default = NL.
Let me know if you have feedback to the logic, that's always
welcome.
Regards,
Paul
de49d99e634d215e26f27e95eed1558769b73cc1.camel AT units.it">Using geteduroam android beta 2.0(516) 2/1/2024 on Samsung Galaxy A71 Android 13 - ITALIANO
When searching for Trieste I get "University of Trieste - Italy" instead of "Università degli Studi di Trieste"
If I search for "Università degli Studi di Trieste" I get no results.
CAT configuration for this institution is :Paese: ItaliaNome Organizzazione default/altre lingue: University of Trieste - ItalyNome Organizzazione English(GB): University of TriesteNome Organizzazione Italiano: Università degli Studi di Trieste
My expected behaviour would be either:1. My device is set up in Italian I expect results in Italian2. I get results in all languages
Could you confirm this behaviour?
--
Daniele AlbrizioUfficio Reti e telefonia | ICT - Phone and Network Management
Università degli Studi di Trieste | University of Trieste
Via Alfonso Valerio 12 - 34127 Trieste (Italy)
daniele.albrizio AT units.it
Tel. | Ph. +39 040 558 3319
Ufficio Reti e telefonia | ICT - Phone and Network Management
Tel. | Ph. +39 040 558 3331
- default/other languages instead of device language in new geteduroam android, ALBRIZIO DANIELE, 01/05/2024
- Re: default/other languages instead of device language in new geteduroam android, Paul Dekkers, 01/05/2024
- Re: default/other languages instead of device language in new geteduroam android, ALBRIZIO DANIELE, 01/05/2024
- Re: default/other languages instead of device language in new geteduroam android, Paul Dekkers, 01/05/2024
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.24.