rare-users - Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition

Subject: RARE user and assistance email list

List archive

Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition

From: Xavier Jeannin <>
To: Frédéric LOUI <>,
Subject: Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition
Date: Mon, 16 Jan 2023 09:41:07 +0100
Dkim-filter: OpenDKIM Filter v2.10.3 zmtaauth04.partage.renater.fr 746B41C000B

Hello Frédéric

I checked available software release from RARE/freeRtr GÉANT repository

-->
DAV0001#tna-list-available
INFO: Checking for release tags of https://bitbucket.software.geant.org/scm/rare /rare-nix.git

Version Status
-------------------------------------------------------------------
1 Installed, no updates available

Should I install experimental version?

FYI

DAV0001#tna-list-installed
Generation Current Release Git Tag                    KernelID       Kernel Release            Platform                   Install date
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
         1         1       release-1                  Debian11_0     5.10.0-8-amd64            accton_wedge100bf_32x      2022-10-03 11:51:55.027031495 +0200
         2 *       2       release-1-92-g2d3b6b7-free Debian11_0     5.10.0-8-amd64            accton_wedge100bf_32x      2022-10-03 12:06:23.071876632 +0200

Regards
Xavier

Le 12/01/2023 à 12:16, Frédéric LOUI a écrit :

Hi Xavier,

We had a quick sync with mc36 yesterday.

Good news, he got his APS2556X-1t back from KIFU long term test.
However, he could not reproduce the issue you observe and concluded there is something specific to your setup
In order to move forward, did you manage to upgrade your image ?

As Alexander is back he might be able to help if something is need from Nix Hydra build server point of view.
Frederic

Le 25 nov. 2022 à 14:55, mc36  a écrit :

hi,
i've just added the local crossconnect to the renater-l2 profile for a quick testing....
please issue tna-install-experimental and tna-switch to it...
then you can do the following:

int bun1.x
exit
int sdn15.x
exit
connect vlanX
side1 bun1.x
side2 sdn15.x
exit

then you can do the ping test... this one is an one-off,
does not involve control plane, only the dataplane is used
without any bridging (mac learning) happening in freerouter...
thanks,
cs


On 11/24/22 14:34, Xavier Jeannin wrote:

Hi
I did again the procedure with sdn10 - same result
1/ _shut __sdn10_
2/ configure on the PPN the bridge/client interface/ interface toward the backbone/
3/ make the ping, this time no Destination Host Unreachable, the ping works directly without need to clear P4 server
below the debug trace
Thank you
Xavier
----
root@nmaas-demo:~# ping 14.14.14.101
PING 14.14.14.101 (14.14.14.101) 56(84) bytes of data.
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=7 ttl=255 time=1.03 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=8 ttl=255 time=1.07 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=9 ttl=255 time=0.781 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=16 ttl=255 time=1.10 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=18 ttl=255 time=0.878 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=19 ttl=255 time=1.11 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=20 ttl=255 time=0.954 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=22 ttl=255 time=0.956 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=23 ttl=255 time=1.05 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=25 ttl=255 time=1.07 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=26 ttl=255 time=1.21 ms
^C
--- 14.14.14.101 ping statistics ---
29 packets transmitted, 11 received, 62% packet loss, time 28358ms
rtt min/avg/max/mdev = 0.781/1.022/1.211/0.115 ms
root@nmaas-demo:~#
-------
DAV0001#debug server p4lang tx
DAV0001#terminal mon
DAV0001#
DAV0001#
DAV0001#
DAV0001#
DAV0001#conf t
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001#configure terminal   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
warning userLineHandler.doExec:userLine.java:874 <nobody> configuring from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg)#interface sdn10
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#interface sdn10   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-if)#shutdown
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-if)#shutdown   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-if)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 0 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 1 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 2 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 3 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 4 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 5 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 6 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 7 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 8 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 9 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 10 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 11 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 12 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 13 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 14 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_mod 512 15 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlelist_mod 512 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: state 52 0 10 0 0 0
DAV0001(cfg-if)#exit
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-if)#exit   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg)#exit
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#exit   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
warning userLineHandler.doExec:userLine.java:906 <nobody> configured from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001#show interfaces summary
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001#show interfaces summary   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
interface     state   tx                                     rx drop
bundle1         up         20719124710+0               20501951807+0 88+0
bundle1.11   up         7552821146+0                 7553275800+7702253608   0+0
bundle1.12   up         605151322+0                   309814524+317070008       0+0
bundle1.15   up         484212+0                         1096028+1594428               0+0
bundle1.16   up         3196211162+0                 3196816772+3260446276   0+0
bundle1.17   up         9154420016+0                 9155031528+9334320796   0+0
bundle1.18   up         16881816+0                     16277596+18109484           0+0
bundle1.19   up         92144368+0                     183909259+206832175       0+0
bvi1               up         0                                       879496 879496
bvi11             up         0                                       0                                           0
bvi2               up         0                                       875226 875226
bvi3               up         284328591                       87154994 1180
bvi4               up         4618                                 630496 621120
bvi5               up         0                                       619650 619650
bvi6               up         0                                       639664 639664
bvi7               up         0                                       614198 614198
ethernet0     up         41603769623                   41405895571                       0
ethernet1     up         0                                       127716227 127716227
ethernet2     up         0                                       42146 42146
sdn10             admin   10420456432+6000012   10310404226+5155623 63536+0
sdn15             up         20789952722+9961568   20808282140+10153556 75144+0
sdn15.11       up         7553275800+0                 7552902182+7701667914   0+0
sdn15.12       up         309814524+0                   605231620+13569364894   0+0
sdn15.15       up         1096028+0                       484212+703734                   0+0
sdn15.16       up         3196816772+0                 3196228108+3259581302 264+0
sdn15.17       up         9155031528+0                 9154420016+9333436392   0+0
sdn15.18       up         16279862+0                     16882766+17231062           0+0
sdn15.19       up         467755476+0                   177746296+213480964       0+0
sdn7               up         10298668278+3737954   10192941765+5166401 1330648+0
DAV0001#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
DAV0001#conf t
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001#configure terminal   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
warning userLineHandler.doExec:userLine.java:874 <nobody> configuring from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg)#bridge 8
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#bridge 8   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#mac-learn
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#mac-learn   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#exit
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#exit   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg)#interfacedebug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
DAV0001(cfg)#server p4lang p4
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#server p4lang p4   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-server)#export-bridge 8
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-server)#export-bridge 8   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-server)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgelabel_add 8 695735
DAV0001(cfg-server)#exit
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-server)#exit   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg)#interface bundle1.14 debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
DAV0001(cfg)#interface bundle1.14
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#interface bundle1.14   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 830 512 14
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 11 514
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 12 515
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 19 518
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 18 520
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 17 522
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 16 523
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 15 526
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 14 830
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 11 514
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 12 515
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 19 518
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 18 520
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 17 522
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 16 523
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 15 526
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 14 830
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 8
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 8   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 830 8
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#exit
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-subif)#exit   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg)#interface bundle1.1debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
DAV0001(cfg)#interface sdn15.14
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#interface sdn15.14   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 1161 12 14
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 8
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 8   from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 1161 8
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgemac_add 8 24:6e:96:4c:3e:1a 1161
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgemac_add 8 00:1f:68:67:12:2b 830
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
Le 24/11/2022    14:21, mc36 a   crit  :

just another question... what if you no shut sdn7 and shut sdn10,
and a quick test on the interface addition and the ping?
thanks,
cs

On 11/24/22 13:56, Xavier Jeannin wrote:

Hi

I did the procedure
1/ shut sdn7
2/ configure on the PPN the bridge/client interface/ interface toward the backbone/
3/ make the ping, at the beginning (4 ping packets) Destination Host Unreachable then ping works without need to clear P4 server

below the debug trace

Thank you
Xavier

---------------------

root@nmaas-demo:~# ping 14.14.14.101
PING 14.14.14.101 (14.14.14.101) 56(84) bytes of data.
 From 14.14.14.44 icmp_seq=1 Destination Host Unreachable
 From 14.14.14.44 icmp_seq=2 Destination Host Unreachable
 From 14.14.14.44 icmp_seq=3 Destination Host Unreachable
 From 14.14.14.44 icmp_seq=4 Destination Host Unreachable
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=6 ttl=255 time=1.69 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=7 ttl=255 time=1.29 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=8 ttl=255 time=1.00 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=9 ttl=255 time=0.934 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=10 ttl=255 time=1.09 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=11 ttl=255 time=0.825 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=12 ttl=255 time=0.900 ms
64 bytes from 14.14.14.101: icmp_seq=13 ttl=255 time=1.05 ms
^C
--- 14.14.14.101 ping statistics ---
13 packets transmitted, 8 received, +4 errors, 38% packet loss, time 12086ms
rtt min/avg/max/mdev = 0.825/1.098/1.692/0.263 ms, pipe 4



--------------

DAV0001#conf t
DAV0001(cfg)#interface sdn7
DAV0001(cfg-if)#shutdown
DAV0001(cfg-if)#exut
invalid command, try     ?

DAV0001(cfg-if)#exit
DAV0001(cfg)#exit
DAV0001#show interfaces ?
      <cr>
      [name]                     - name of (sub)interface
      bpratio                 - byte by packet ratio
      bundle1                 - name of (sub)interface
      bundle1.11     - name of (sub)interface
      bundle1.12     - name of (sub)interface
      bundle1.15     - name of (sub)interface
      bundle1.16     - name of (sub)interface
      bundle1.17     - name of (sub)interface
      bundle1.18     - name of (sub)interface
      bundle1.19     - name of (sub)interface
      bvi1                             - name of (sub)interface
      bvi11                         - name of (sub)interface
      bvi2                             - name of (sub)interface
      bvi3                             - name of (sub)interface
      bvi4                             - name of (sub)interface
      bvi5                             - name of (sub)interface
      bvi6                             - name of (sub)interface
      bvi7                             - name of (sub)interface
      description - description listing
      ethernet0         - name of (sub)interface
      ethernet1         - name of (sub)interface
      ethernet2         - name of (sub)interface
      full                             - full listing
      hwbwmon                 - hardware bandwidth monitor listing
      hwpsummary     - hardware packet summary listing
      hwptotal             - hardware packet total listing
      hwptraffic     - hardware packet traffic listing
      hwsummary         - hardware summary listing
      hwswpratio     - hardware by software packets
      hwswratio         - hardware by software bytes
      hwtotal                 - hardware total listing
      hwtraffic         - hardware traffic listing
      lastio                     - last packet listing
      psummary             - packet summary listing
      ptotal                     - packet total listing
      ptraffic             - packet traffic listing
      sdn10                         - name of (sub)interface
      sdn15                         - name of (sub)interface
      sdn15.11             - name of (sub)interface
      sdn15.12             - name of (sub)interface
      sdn15.15             - name of (sub)interface
      sdn15.16             - name of (sub)interface
      sdn15.17             - name of (sub)interface
      sdn15.18             - name of (sub)interface
      sdn15.19             - name of (sub)interface
      sdn7                             - name of (sub)interface
      status                     - status listing
      summary                 - summary listing
      swbwmon                 - software bandwidth monitor listing
      swpsummary     - software packet summary listing
      swptotal             - software packet total listing
      swptraffic     - software packet traffic listing
      swsummary         - software summary listing
      swtotal                 - software total listing
      swtraffic         - software traffic listing
      total                         - total listing
      traffic                 - traffic listing
      vrf                                 - vrf listing
      |                                         - output modifier

DAV0001#show interfaces summary
interface         state     tx                                                                         rx drop
bundle1                 up                 20716483642+0 20500388682+0 88+0
bundle1.11     up                 7552820750+0 7553275052+7702251880     0+0
bundle1.12     up                 605151102+0 309813908+317068600             0+0
bundle1.15     up                 484124+0 1095588+1593276                             0+0
bundle1.16     up                 3196211162+0 3196816332+3260445252     0+0
bundle1.17     up                 9154419972+0 9155031176+9334319708     0+0
bundle1.18     up                 14338326+0 14936502+15512902                     0+0
bundle1.19     up                 92062476+0 183700400+206420172             0+0
bvi1                             up 0                                                                             879144 879144
bvi11                         up 0 0                                                                                     0
bvi2                             up 0                                                                             874830 874830
bvi3                             up                 284052669 87071002 1180
bvi4                             up 4618                                                                 628604 619228
bvi5                             up 0                                                                             619342 619342
bvi6                             up 0                                                                             639224 639224
bvi7                             up 0                                                                             613846 613846
ethernet0         up                 41599272454 41400199439                                             0
ethernet1         up                 0 127473607 127473607
ethernet2         up                 0 42088 42088
sdn10                         up                 10418026448+3514000 10308943430+3659916 240+0
sdn15                         up                 20788110095+8066887 20805552008+7342370 75144+0
sdn15.11             up                 7553275052+0 7552901786+7701667338     0+0
sdn15.12             up                 309813908+0 605231400+13569364574     0+0
sdn15.15             up                 1095588+0 484124+703606                                     0+0
sdn15.16             up                 3196816332+0 3196228108+3259581302 264+0
sdn15.17             up                 9155031176+0 9154419972+9333436328     0+0
sdn15.18             up                 14938768+0 14339276+14635312                     0+0
sdn15.19             up                 467271067+0 177581424+213285690             0+0
sdn7                             admin     10298457194+3528220 10191453797+3644057 8305+0

DAV0001#debug server p4lang p4
invalid command, try debug server p4lang ?

DAV0001#debug server p4lang p4 tx
invalid command, try debug server p4lang ?

DAV0001#debug server p4lang tx
DAV0001#terminal monitor
DAV0001#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
DAV0001#conf t
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001#configure terminal     from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 4619 6
warning userLineHandler.doExec:userLine.java:874 <nobody> configuring from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg)#bridge 8
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#bridge 8     from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#mac-learn
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#mac-learn     from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 461 96
DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#exit
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#exit     from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg)#server p4lang p4
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#server p4lang p4     from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 4 6196
DAV0001(cfg-server)#export-bridge debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
DAV0001(cfg-server)#export-bridge 8
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-server)#export-bridge 8     from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0 .0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-server)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgelabel_add 8 324285
DAV0001(cfg-server)#interface bundle1.14 debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
DAV0001(cfg-server)#interface bundle1.14
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-server)#interface bundle1.14     from local:telnet <loop> 23 ->     127.0.0.1 46196
% no such interface
DAV0001(cfg-server)#exit
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-server)#exit     from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg)#interface bundle1.14
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#interface bundle1.14     from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0 .1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 15761 512 14
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 11 514
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 12 515
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 19 518
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 18 520
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 17 522
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 16 523
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 15 526
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 14 15761
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 11 514
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 12 515
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 19 518
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 18 520
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 17 522
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 16 523
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 15 526
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 14 15761
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 8
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 8     from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0 .1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 15761 8
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#exit
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-subif)#exit     from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
DAV0001(cfg)#interface sdn15.14
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#interface sdn15.14     from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1     46196
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 7576 12 14
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 8
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 8     from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0 .1 46196
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#edebug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 7576 8
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#exit
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-subif)#exit     from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46196
DAV0001(cfg)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgemac_add 8 24:6e:96:4c:3e:1a 7576
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgemac_add 8 00:1f:68:67:12:2b 15761
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive


Le 24/11/2022       12:28, mc36 a     crit   :

hi,
for a quick test could you please shut down the sdn7 for example,
and do the vlan addition test... please let the debug on and drop
me the output...
rationale: my guess is that the issue relates to the hardware hashing somehow...
thanks,
cs


On 11/24/22 12:25, Xavier Jeannin wrote:

Le 24/11/2022             12:15, mc36 a         crit     :

hi,
i see exactly the same messages related to the port in both cases...
just one question, how many 10g interfaces are interconnecting the cpe and the switch?

3 10g interfaces - SDN7, SDN10 and SDN15

Regards
Xavier

i see two ports in the outputs, the sdn7 and sdn10?
thanks,
cs

On 11/24/22 12:01, Xavier Jeannin wrote:

here it is

after the clear the ping starts

DAV0001#
DAV0001#clear p4lang p4
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001#clear p4lang p4                 from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001#error servP4langConn.run:servP4langConn.java:146 neighbor 127.0.0.1 down
info cfgPrcss.doRound:cfgPrcss.java:509 restarting process bffwd
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: ports_add 12 10 0 0 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: ports_add 52 10 0 0 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: ports_add 176 10 0 0 0
warning servP4langConn.doNegot:servP4langConn.java:307 neighbor 127.0.0.1 up
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: mylabel4_add 258684 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgelabel_add 1 854040
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgelabel_add 2 1028491
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgelabel_add 3 363618
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgelabel_add 4 334103
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgelabel_add 5 464687
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgelabel_add 6 688411
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgelabel_add 7 861309
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgelabel_add 8 297952
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgelabel_add 11 875419
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 528 512 14
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 528 8
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 527 12 14
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 527 8
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 526 512 15
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 526 7
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 525 12 15
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 525 7
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 524 12 16
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 524 6
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 523 512 16
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 523 6
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 522 512 17
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 522 5
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 521 12 17
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 521 5
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 520 512 18
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 520 4
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 519 12 18
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 519 4
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 518 512 19
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 518 3
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 517 12 19
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 517 3
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 516 12 12
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 516 2
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 515 512 12
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 515 2
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 514 512 11
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 514 1
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 513 12 11
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 513 1
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 11 514
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 12 515
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 19 518
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 18 520
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 17 522
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 16 523
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 15 526
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 14 528
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 11 514
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 12 515
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 19 518
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 18 520
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 17 522
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 16 523
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 15 526
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 14 528
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: state 176 1 10 0 0 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: mtu 176 1500
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: state 52 1 10 0 0 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: mtu 52 1500
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: state 12 1 10 0 0 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: mtu 12 1500
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: polkaown_add 0 1
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: myaddr4_add 224.0.0.0/4 -1 1
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: myaddr4_add 255.255.255.255/32 -1 1
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: myaddr6_add ff00::/8 -1 1
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: myaddr4_add 19.19.19.0/24 -1 1
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: myaddr4_add 19.19.19.1/32 -1 1
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: mylabel6_add 121802 1
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: mylabel4_add 774199 1
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 0 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 1 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 2 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 3 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 4 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 5 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 6 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 7 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 8 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 9 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 10 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 11 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 12 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 13 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 14 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 15 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlelist_add 512 52 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 0 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 1 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 2 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 3 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 4 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 5 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 6 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 7 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 8 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 9 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 10 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 11 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 12 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 13 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 14 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_del 512 15 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlelist_del 512 0
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 0 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 1 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 2 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 3 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 4 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 5 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 6 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 7 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 8 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 9 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 10 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 11 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 12 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 13 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 14 52
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbundle_add 512 15 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlelist_add 512 52 176
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgemac_add 3 00:1f:68:67:12:2b 518
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgemac_add 3 24:6e:96:4c:3e:1a 517
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgemac_add 4 00:1f:68:67:12:2b 520
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgemac_add 4 24:6e:96:4c:3e:1a 519
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgemac_add 8 00:1f:68:67:12:2b 528
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgemac_add 8 24:6e:96:4c:3e:1a 527

Le 24/11/2022                         11:51, mc36 a                 crit :

hi,
okkk, it's ok for now...

ter mon
deb serv p4 tx
cle p4 p4

and gimme the results please...
thanks,
cs


On 11/24/22 11:43, Xavier Jeannin wrote:

Hello Csaba

Second debug session with ping
Note that in your instruction the first "sdn1.X" is in fact the Bundle interface :


DAV0001#
DAV0001#debug server p4lang tx
DAV0001#terminal monitor
DAV0001#conf t
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001#configure terminal from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
warning userLineHandler.doExec:userLine.java:874 <nobody> configuring from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001(cfg)#bridebug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
DAV0001(cfg)#bridge 8
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#bridge 8                                 from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#mac-learn
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#mac-learn from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#exit
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#exit                                 from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001(cfg)#server p4lang p4
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#server p4lang p4                                 from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001(cfg-server)#export-bridge 8debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
DAV0001(cfg-server)#export-bridge 8
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-server)#export-bridge 8                                 from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001(cfg-server)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgelabel_add 8 297952
DAV0001(cfg-server)#
DAV0001(cfg-server)#
DAV0001(cfg-server)#exit
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-server)#exit from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001(cfg)#interface bundle1.14
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#interface bundle1.14                                 from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 4822 512 14
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 11 514
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 12 515
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 19 518
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 18 520
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 17 522
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 16 523
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 15 526
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 52 14 4822
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 11 514
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 12 515
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 19 518
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 18 520
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 17 522
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 16 523
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 15 526
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bundlevlan_add 176 14 4822
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 8
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 8                                 from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 4822 8
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#exit
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-subif)#exit                                 from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001(cfg)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
DAV0001(cfg)#interface sdn15.14
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#interface sdn15.14                                 from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 4505 12 14
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 8debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 8
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 8                                 from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 4505 8
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#exit
<------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Ping started -----------------------

info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg-subif)#exit                                 from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001(cfg)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgemac_add 8 00:1f:68:67:12:2b 4822
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgemac_add 8 24:6e:96:4c:3e:1a 4505
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
DAV0001(cfg)#exit
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001(cfg)#exit from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
warning userLineHandler.doExec:userLine.java:906 <nobody> configured from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
DAV0001#
DAV0001#
DAV0001#show p4lang p4 done-bridge debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
DAV0001#show p4lang p4 done-bridge 8
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001#show p4lang p4 done-bridge 8                                 from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
packet byte
addr iface static time tx                                 rx drop                                 tx rx drop
001f.6867.122b                                 bundle1.14 false                                                                 00:01:30 1                                                                 2 0 44 88                                 0
246e.964c.3e1a                                 sdn15.14 false 00:01:30 2                                                                 2 0 88 88                                 0

DAV0001#show p4lang p4 done-interface
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1087 command DAV0001#show p4lang p4 done-interface                                 from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 46184
sent                                 name
12 ifc sdn15
52 ifc sdn10
176                                                                 ifc sdn7
512                                                                 ifc bundle1
513                                                                 ifc sdn15.11
514                                                                 ifc bundle1.11
515                                                                 ifc bundle1.12
516                                                                 ifc sdn15.12
517                                                                 ifc sdn15.19
518                                                                 ifc bundle1.19
519                                                                 ifc sdn15.18
520                                                                 ifc bundle1.18
521                                                                 ifc sdn15.17
522                                                                 ifc bundle1.17
523                                                                 ifc bundle1.16
524                                                                 ifc sdn15.16
525                                                                 ifc sdn15.15
526                                                                 ifc bundle1.15
4505                                 ifc sdn15.14
4822                                 ifc bundle1.14

Le 24/11/2022                                                 04:40, mc36 a                                 crit :

debug server p4 tx
term mon
bridge x
                mac-learn
server p4 p4
                export-bridge x
int sdn1.x
                bridge-group x
int sdn15.x
                bridge-group x
!!! do the ping test through the bridge....
sho p4 p4 done-bridge x
sho p4 p4 done-inter


On 11/24/22 04:37, mc36 wrote:

hi,
let's do the following:

debug server p4 tx
term mon
bridge x
                                                                mac-learn
server p4 p4
                                                                export-bridge x
int sdn1.x
                                                                bridge-group x
int sdn15.x
                                                                bridge-group x
sho p4 p4 done-bridge x
sho p4 p4 done-inter

please give me the whole transcript, including when you configure...
thanks,
cs



On 10/28/22 16:32, Xavier Jeannin wrote:

Hello Csaba

Just to let you know that the demonstration went fine and now we will continue the installation on the field.
It could take while as our engineering team has now to define where and how to deploy, and as we are moving a big PoP and also as the way the implementation is done within RENATER is not very reactive

Best regards
Xavier

Le 27/10/2022 09:37, Xavier Jeannin a crit                                 :

Hello Csaba,

Thank you very much for your attention to our case.

I will make a demonstration today of the PPN at 1pm to my CTO for a validation to go for an implementation, so I will no touch anything before this.
This morning, I have urgent things to work on and my afternoon and tomorrow is already full
I will try to make the test either this afternoon or tomorrow.
If I cannot do it during this period, I will on vacation next week. Unfortunately, my daughter just get a strong thyroid disease, so I will take of her trying to relieve her of the work of caring for her newborn child.
Therefore, I will back only the 7th Nov. and I will restart the debug process.

I really appreciate your help

Thank you for your understanding
Regards
Xavier

Le 27/10/2022 08:44, mc36 a crit                                 :

hi,
could you please confirm if you configure in the following order then it works immediately without clearing p4?

bridge x
                                mac-learn
server p4 p4
                                export-bridge x
int bun1.x
                                bridge-gr x
int sdn15.x
                                bridge-gr x

thanks,
cs


On 10/26/22 14:35, mc36 wrote:

hi,
:) those are just the debug outputs i've enabled to see whats going on...
btw im in the conference but imho you cannot hear me...
br,
cs


On 10/26/22 14:31,  wrote:

Hello

Le 26/10/2022 13:26, mc36 a crit                                                                 :

hi,
i've given a spin to your setup but it works here immediately...
can you try with the below sequence if it fails for you please?
thanks,
cs


sid(cfg)#bridge 11
sid(cfg-brdg)#
sid(cfg)#server p4lang p4 debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
sid(cfg)#server p4lang p4
sid(cfg-server)#export-bridge 11
sid(cfg-server)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgelabel_add 11 671317

invalid command

/DAV0001(cfg-server)#$.java:1114 fwd0 tx: bridgelabel_add 11 671317//
//invalid command, try ?//
//
//DAV0001(cfg-server)#debug//
//invalid command, try ?/

Would you like to make a quick VC to debug this?

https://rendez-vous.renater.fr/ppn

Regards
Xavier

sid(cfg)#interface bundle1.11
sid(cfg-subif)#brdebug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portvlan_add 27038 3469 11
sid(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 11
sid(cfg-subif)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_add 27038 11
sid(cfg-subif)#
sid(cfg-subif)#
sid(cfg)#interface sdn2
sid(cfg-if)#bridge-group 11
sid(cfg-if)#debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: portbridge_mod 2 11
debug servP4langCfg.sendLine:servP4langCfg.java:1114 fwd0 tx: keepalive
sid#ping 1.1.1.1 vrf v3
pinging 1.1.1.1, src="null," vrf=v3, cnt=5, len=64, df=false, tim=1000, gap=0, ttl=255, tos=0, sgt=0, flow=0, fill=0, alrt=-1, sweep=false, multi=false
!!!!!


On 10/26/22 12:58, Xavier Jeannin wrote:

Hi,

you mentioned that export-bridge was not necessary if thee is no IP@ on the bvi. I prefer this because it was my first understanding. So all is perfect :-)

I add a new user with the export-bridge got the the same result. The ping start to work when I clear the p4lang server.
I hope I have not once again made a misconfiguration :-( (Apologies in advance if it was the cas)

/
/

/root@nmaas-demo:~# ping 16.16.16.101//
//PING 16.16.16.101 (16.16.16.101) 56(84) bytes of data.//
//64 bytes from 16.16.16.101: icmp_seq=133 ttl=255 time=1.16 ms//
//64 bytes from 16.16.16.101: icmp_seq=134 ttl=255 time=0.866 ms//
//64 bytes from 16.16.16.101: icmp_seq=135 ttl=255 time=1.03 ms//
//64 bytes from 16.16.16.101: icmp_seq=136 ttl=255 time=1.20 ms//
//64 bytes from 16.16.16.101: icmp_seq=137 ttl=255 time=0.999 ms//
//64 bytes from 16.16.16.101: icmp_seq=138 ttl=255 time=0.811 ms//
//64 bytes from 16.16.16.101: icmp_seq=139 ttl=255 time=1.03 ms//
//^C//
//--- 16.16.16.101 ping statistics ---//
//139 packets transmitted, 7 received, 94% packet loss, time 141201ms//
//rtt min/avg/max/mdev = 0.811/1.016/1.205/0.133 ms/


DAV0001#clear p4lang p4
DAV0001#show running-config hide
hostname DAV0001
buggy
!
logging buffered debug 10240
logging file debug /var/log/freertr.log
logging rotate 655360000 /var/log/freertr.old
!
aaa userlist usr
username rare
exit
!
bundle 1
loadbalance round
exit
!
bridge 1
mac-learn
exit
!
bridge 2
mac-learn
exit
!
bridge 3
mac-learn
exit
!
bridge 4
mac-learn
exit
!
bridge 5
mac-learn
exit
!
bridge 6
mac-learn
exit
!
vrf definition inet
exit
!
vrf definition p4
exit
!
interface bundle1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.11
bridge-group 1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.12
bridge-group 2
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.16
bridge-group 6
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.17
bridge-group 5
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.18
bridge-group 4
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.19
bridge-group 3
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi2
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi3
vrf forwarding inet
ipv4 address 19.19.19.1 255.255.255.0
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi4
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi5
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi6
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface ethernet0
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface ethernet1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface ethernet2
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn10
mtu 1500
macaddr 002b.1540.1530
bundle-group 1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15
mtu 1500
macaddr 007c.326c.7058
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.11
bridge-group 1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.12
bridge-group 2
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.16
bridge-group 6
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.17
bridge-group 5
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.18
bridge-group 4
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.19
bridge-group 3
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn7
mtu 1500
macaddr 006c.6722.2e73
bundle-group 1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
sensor ifaces-hw
path interfaces-hw/interface/counter
prefix freertr-ifaces
prepend iface_hw_byte_
command sho inter hwsumm
name 0 ifc=
key name interfaces-hw/interface
replace \. _
column 1 name st
column 1 replace admin -1
column 1 replace down 0
column 1 replace up 1
column 2 name tx
column 3 name rx
column 4 name dr
exit
!
sensor ifaces-sw
path interfaces-sw/interface/counter
prefix freertr-ifaces
prepend iface_sw_byte_
command sho inter swsumm
name 0 ifc=
key name interfaces-sw/interface
replace \. _
column 1 name st
column 1 replace admin -1
column 1 replace down 0
column 1 replace up 1
column 2 name tx
column 3 name rx
column 4 name dr
exit
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
server telnet p4
security protocol telnet
exec logging
no exec authorization
no login authentication
login logging
vrf p4
exit
!
server telnet telnet
no exec authorization
no login authentication
vrf p4
exit
!
server p4lang p4
export-vrf inet
export-bridge 1
export-bridge 2
export-bridge 3
export-bridge 4
export-bridge 5
export-bridge 6
export-port sdn15 12 10 0 0 0
export-port sdn10 52 10 0 0 0
export-port sdn7 176 10 0 0 0
export-port bundle1 dynamic 0 0 0 0
interconnect ethernet0
vrf p4
exit
!
server prometheus pr
sensor ifaces-hw
sensor ifaces-sw
interface bvi3
vrf inet
exit
!
!
end

Regards
Xavier

Le 26/10/2022 12:08, mc36 a crit :

hi,
so you missed the required stanza export-bridge 5 under p4lang server again... :)
can you give that a try without the clearing?
br,
cs


On 10/26/22 12:03,  wrote:

Hi

Thank you Csaba. I was in a meeting

It was also my understanding that export-bridge was required but in one of your email ...
Whatever I update the configuration according to your advice I just keep the @IP on the bvi3 as it is used for the monitoring

So for all others clients, no IP address on the PPN.
I just add a new client 17 and same problem

/DAV0001#conf t//
//DAV0001(cfg)#bridge 5//
//DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#mac-learn//
//DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#exit//
//DAV0001(cfg)#interface sdn15.17//
//DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 5//
//DAV0001(cfg-subif)#exit//
//DAV0001(cfg)#interface bundle1.17//
//DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 5//
//DAV0001(cfg-subif)#exit//
//DAV0001(cfg)#exit/

--> then configuration of the PE
--> Ping /
root@nmaas-demo:~# ping 17.17.17.101//
//PING 17.17.17.101 (17.17.17.101) 56(84) bytes of data./
--> no work
--> /DAV0001#clear p4lang p4/
then the ping works /
64 bytes from 17.17.17.101: icmp_seq=231 ttl=255 time=1.14 ms//
//64 bytes from 17.17.17.101: icmp_seq=232 ttl=255 time=1.03 ms//
//64 bytes from 17.17.17.101: icmp_seq=233 ttl=255 time=1.05 ms//
//^C//
//--- 17.17.17.101 ping statistics ---//
//233 packets transmitted, 3 received, 98% packet loss, time 237505ms//
//rtt min/avg/max/mdev = 1.032/1.078/1.148/0.062 ms/

Regards
Xavier


DAV0001#show running-config hide
hostname DAV0001
buggy
!
logging buffered debug 10240
logging file debug /var/log/freertr.log
logging rotate 655360000 /var/log/freertr.old
!
aaa userlist usr
username rare
exit
!
bundle 1
loadbalance round
exit
!
bridge 1
mac-learn
exit
!
bridge 2
mac-learn
exit
!
bridge 3
mac-learn
exit
!
bridge 4
mac-learn
exit
!
bridge 5
mac-learn
exit
!
vrf definition inet
exit
!
vrf definition p4
exit
!
interface bundle1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.11
bridge-group 1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.12
bridge-group 2
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.17
bridge-group 5
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.18
bridge-group 4
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.19
bridge-group 3
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi2
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi3
vrf forwarding inet
ipv4 address 19.19.19.1 255.255.255.0
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi4
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi5
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface ethernet0
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface ethernet1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface ethernet2
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn10
mtu 1500
macaddr 002b.1540.1530
bundle-group 1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15
mtu 1500
macaddr 007c.326c.7058
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.11
bridge-group 1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.12
bridge-group 2
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.17
bridge-group 5
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.18
bridge-group 4
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.19
bridge-group 3
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn7
mtu 1500
macaddr 006c.6722.2e73
bundle-group 1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
sensor ifaces-hw
path interfaces-hw/interface/counter
prefix freertr-ifaces
prepend iface_hw_byte_
command sho inter hwsumm
name 0 ifc=
key name interfaces-hw/interface
replace \. _
column 1 name st
column 1 replace admin -1
column 1 replace down 0
column 1 replace up 1
column 2 name tx
column 3 name rx
column 4 name dr
exit
!
sensor ifaces-sw
path interfaces-sw/interface/counter
prefix freertr-ifaces
prepend iface_sw_byte_
command sho inter swsumm
name 0 ifc=
key name interfaces-sw/interface
replace \. _
column 1 name st
column 1 replace admin -1
column 1 replace down 0
column 1 replace up 1
column 2 name tx
column 3 name rx
column 4 name dr
exit
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
server telnet p4
security protocol telnet
exec logging
no exec authorization
no login authentication
login logging
vrf p4
exit
!
server telnet telnet
no exec authorization
no login authentication
vrf p4
exit
!
server p4lang p4
export-vrf inet
export-bridge 3
export-port sdn15 12 10 0 0 0
export-port sdn10 52 10 0 0 0
export-port sdn7 176 10 0 0 0
export-port bundle1 dynamic 0 0 0 0
interconnect ethernet0
vrf p4
exit
!
server prometheus pr
sensor ifaces-hw
sensor ifaces-sw
interface bvi3
vrf inet
exit
!
!
end

Le 26/10/2022 10:03, mc36 a crit :

hi,
what i can see here is that you're assigning an ip to the bvi which should be avoided...
and finally, i really have no idea how it works as the export-bridge 4 under p4lang is missing?
br,
cs

On 10/26/22 09:45,  wrote:

thank you Csaba

here it is

---------- configuration of the VLAN to connect the client ---
DAV0001#conf t
DAV0001(cfg)#bridge 4
DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#mac-learn
DAV0001(cfg-brdg)#exit
DAV0001(cfg)#interface sdn15.18
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 4
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#exit
DAV0001(cfg)#interface bvi4
DAV0001(cfg-if)#vrf forwarding inet
DAV0001(cfg-if)#ipv4 address 18.18.18.1 255.255.255.0
DAV0001(cfg-if)#exit
DAV0001(cfg)#exit
DAV0001#ping 18.18.18.1 vrf inet
pinging 18.18.18.1, src="null," vrf=inet, cnt=5, len=64, df=false, tim=1000, gap=0, ttl=255, tos=0, sgt=0, flow=0, fill=0, alrt=-1, sweep=false, multi=false
!!!!!
result=100.0%, recv/sent/lost/err=5/5/0/0, took 1, min/avg/max/dev rtt=0/0.1/1/0.1, ttl 255/255/255/0.0, tos 0/0.0/0/0.0

DAV0001#show ipv4 arp bvi4
mac address time static
246e.964c.3e1a 18.18.18.44 00:00:37 false

-----------------

DAV0001#clear p4lang p4

----> then ping with client works

------------- configuration bundle for connection to the PE ------------

DAV0001#conf t
DAV0001(cfg)#interface bundle1.18
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#bridge-group 4
DAV0001(cfg-subif)#exit
-------------

DAV0001#clear p4lang p4
----> then ping from client to PE works

Regards
Xavier

Le 26/10/2022 09:29, mc36 a crit :

hi,
could you please give me the exact cli commands you execute on the rare box?
then maybe i can fix the issue... :)
(it must be a bug somewhere in the freerouter exporting process...)
thanks,
cs



On 10/26/22 09:26,  wrote:

Hello

In my use case (see below graph) , from time to time, I will have to add a new 'virtual' interface (bundle1.12 ... bundle1.15 etc ...) for each client.
I notice that I need to make a 'clear p4lang p4' on the PPN, each time I add a client.
This annoy me because it will generate traffic perturbation when adding a new client on the traffic of all other clients.

Maybe I do not configure correctly me P4lang server

/DAV0001#show running-config server p4lang p4//
//server p4lang p4//
// export-vrf inet//
// export-port sdn15 12 10 0 0 0//
// export-port sdn10 52 10 0 0 0//
// export-port sdn7 176 10 0 0 0//
// export-port bundle1 dynamic 0 0 0 0//
// interconnect ethernet0//
// vrf p4//
// exit/

Here is the description of the steps I follow to add a client :

1/ I create a VLAN between the client (here a linux machine) and the PPN Wedge; I implement a bridge on the PPN and put an address on the bvi of the bridge to check the connectivity
then
On the client - Ping from client to the bvi on the PNN -- failed
On the PPN - clear p4lang p4
then the Ping works

2/ I implement the connection between the PPN and the PE (Bundle configuration on the PPN and on the PE)
The
On the client - Ping from client to the end of the bundle on the PE -- failed
On the PE - clear p4lang p4
On the client - Ping from client to the end of the bundle on the PE -- still ailed
On the PPN - clear p4lang p4
then the Ping works


Any idea ?
My conf is below

Thank you
Xavier


DAV0001#show running-config hide
hostname DAV0001
buggy
!
logging buffered debug 10240
logging file debug /var/log/freertr.log
logging rotate 655360000 /var/log/freertr.old
!
aaa userlist usr
username rare
exit
!
bundle 1
loadbalance round
exit
!
bridge 1
mac-learn
exit
!
bridge 2
mac-learn
exit
!
bridge 3
mac-learn
exit
!
bridge 4
mac-learn
exit
!
vrf definition inet
exit
!
vrf definition p4
exit
!
interface bundle1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.11
bridge-group 1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.12
bridge-group 2
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.18
bridge-group 4
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bundle1.19
bridge-group 3
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi2
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi3
vrf forwarding inet
ipv4 address 19.19.19.1 255.255.255.0
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface bvi4
vrf forwarding inet
ipv4 address 18.18.18.1 255.255.255.0
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface ethernet0
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface ethernet1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface ethernet2
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn10
mtu 1500
macaddr 002b.1540.1530
bundle-group 1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15
mtu 1500
macaddr 007c.326c.7058
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.11
bridge-group 1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.12
bridge-group 2
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.18
bridge-group 4
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn15.19
bridge-group 3
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
interface sdn7
mtu 1500
macaddr 006c.6722.2e73
bundle-group 1
no shutdown
no log-link-change
exit
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
sensor ifaces-hw
path interfaces-hw/interface/counter
prefix freertr-ifaces
prepend iface_hw_byte_
command sho inter hwsumm
name 0 ifc=
key name interfaces-hw/interface
replace \. _
column 1 name st
column 1 replace admin -1
column 1 replace down 0
column 1 replace up 1
column 2 name tx
column 3 name rx
column 4 name dr
exit
!
sensor ifaces-sw
path interfaces-sw/interface/counter
prefix freertr-ifaces
prepend iface_sw_byte_
command sho inter swsumm
name 0 ifc=
key name interfaces-sw/interface
replace \. _
column 1 name st
column 1 replace admin -1
column 1 replace down 0
column 1 replace up 1
column 2 name tx
column 3 name rx
column 4 name dr
exit
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
server telnet p4
security protocol telnet
exec logging
no exec authorization
no login authentication
login logging
vrf p4
exit
!
server telnet telnet
no exec authorization
no login authentication
vrf p4
exit
!
server p4lang p4
export-vrf inet
export-port sdn15 12 10 0 0 0
export-port sdn10 52 10 0 0 0
export-port sdn7 176 10 0 0 0
export-port bundle1 dynamic 0 0 0 0
interconnect ethernet0
vrf p4
exit
!
server prometheus pr
sensor ifaces-hw
sensor ifaces-sw
interface bvi3
vrf inet
exit
!
!
end


-- 
Xavier JEANNIN
Network Dpt.
GN4-3 Network technology evolution (WP6 T1) task leader
T l. : +33 1 5394 2042
Mob. : +33 6 3017 0963
www.renater.fr

-- 
Xavier JEANNIN
Network Dpt.
GN4-3 Network technology evolution (WP6 T1) task leader
T l. : +33 1 5394 2042
Mob. : +33 6 3017 0963
www.renater.fr

-- 
Xavier JEANNIN
Network Dpt.
GN4-3 Network technology evolution (WP6 T1) task leader
T                                                                                                                                 l. : +33 1 5394 2042
Mob. : +33 6 3017 0963
www.renater.fr

-- 
Xavier JEANNIN
Network Dpt.
GN4-3 Network technology evolution (WP6 T1) task leader
T                                                                 l. : +33 1 5394 2042
Mob. : +33 6 3017 0963
www.renater.fr

_._,_._,_
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Groups.io Links:

You receive all messages sent to this group.

View/Reply Online (#814) <https://groups.io/g/freertr/message/814> | Reply To Group  | Reply To Sender  | Mute This Topic <https://groups.io/mt/94576914/6006518> | New Topic <https://groups.io/g/freertr/post>
Your Subscription <https://groups.io/g/freertr/editsub/6006518> | Contact Group Owner  | Unsubscribe <https://groups.io/g/freertr/unsub> []

_._,_._,_

-- 
Xavier JEANNIN
Network Dpt.
GN4-3 Network technology evolution (WP6 T1) task leader
T     l. : +33 1 5394 2042
Mob. : +33 6 3017 0963
www.renater.fr

-- 
Xavier JEANNIN
Network Dpt.
GN4-3 Network technology evolution (WP6 T1) task leader
T  l. : +33 1 5394 2042
Mob. : +33 6 3017 0963
www.renater.fr

-- 
Xavier JEANNIN
Network product Dpt.
Tél. : +33 1 5394 2042
Mob. : +33 6 3017 0963
www.renater.fr

Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition, Frédéric LOUI, 01/12/2023
- Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition, Xavier Jeannin, 01/16/2023
  - Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition, mc36, 01/16/2023
    - Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition, Xavier Jeannin, 01/16/2023
      - Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition, mc36, 01/16/2023
        
        Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition, Xavier Jeannin, 01/16/2023
        
        Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition, mc36, 01/16/2023
        
        Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition, Xavier Jeannin, 01/16/2023
        Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition, Xavier Jeannin, 01/16/2023
        Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition, mc36, 01/16/2023
        Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition, Xavier Jeannin, 01/16/2023
        Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition, Xavier Jeannin, 01/16/2023

List archive

Re: [RARE-users] [freertr] clear p4lang p4 - required in case of interface addition