Rare project developers

[mc36 <>]

hi

sorry for the late reply i'll fix this a bit later, i just got my asterfuston
and i also need to develop a bit for the eantc according to yesterday vc with
simon and the whole juniper development team :)

the issue is the following:
see below the config generated at each level for my ibgp toward my rrs....
also the xmlized version of the same output...

your issue is the following:

"
<config><router><bgp4><identifier-value>identifier-escape&#54;5535

</identifier-value></bgp4></router>
<router><bgp4><identifier-value><vrf><inet>
</inet></vrf>
"

this </bgp4</bgp> is here because it deserialized thet router bgp4 65535 
first at level1
then it deserialized the same but at level2...

i'll add a check about if the level1.command==level2.preface then just skip 
the current line from deserialization...

but just after the asterfuston handoff to alex and my current main interest, 
preparation for a proper bgp-ct eantc plugfest....

thx,
cs




noti#show running-config router bgp4 65535 | level
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1141 command noti#show running-config router 
bgp4 65535 | level  from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 41076
2023-03-02 13:48:55
|router bgp4 65535|
router bgp4 65535| vrf inet|
router bgp4 65535| local-as 65535|
router bgp4 65535| router-id 10.10.10.11|
router bgp4 65535| address-family unicast multicast ouni omlt flowspec oflw vpnuni vpnmlt vpnflw ovpnuni ovpnmlt ovpnflw vpls mspw evpn mdt nsh rpd rtfilter srte osrt linkstate 
mvpn omvpn|
router bgp4 65535| monitor bmp inet 10.10.10.10 17971|
router bgp4 65535| !|
router bgp4 65535| template r remote-as 65535|
router bgp4 65535| template r local-as 65535|
router bgp4 65535| template r address-family unicast multicast ouni omlt flowspec oflw vpnuni vpnmlt vpnflw ovpnuni ovpnmlt ovpnflw vpls mspw evpn mdt nsh rpd rtfilter srte osrt 
linkstate mvpn omvpn|
router bgp4 65535| template r distance 200|
router bgp4 65535| template r connection-mode active|
router bgp4 65535| template r compression both|
router bgp4 65535| template r additional-path-rx unicast multicast vpnuni 
vpnmlt|
router bgp4 65535| template r additional-path-tx unicast multicast vpnuni 
vpnmlt|
router bgp4 65535| template r update-source loopback0|
router bgp4 65535| template r monitor bmp|
router bgp4 65535| template r hostname domain|
router bgp4 65535| template r software|
router bgp4 65535| template r extended-open|
router bgp4 65535| template r extended-update|
router bgp4 65535| template r aigp|
router bgp4 65535| template r traffeng|
router bgp4 65535| template r pmsitun|
router bgp4 65535| template r tunenc|
router bgp4 65535| template r linkstate|
router bgp4 65535| template r attribset|
router bgp4 65535| template r unknowns-out all|
router bgp4 65535| template r unknowns-in all|
router bgp4 65535| template r segrout|
router bgp4 65535| template r bier|
router bgp4 65535| template r role attrib|
router bgp4 65535| template r send-community all|
router bgp4 65535| !|
router bgp4 65535| neighbor 10.5.1.10 template r|
router bgp4 65535| !|
router bgp4 65535| neighbor 10.26.26.2 template r|
router bgp4 65535| !|
router bgp4 65535| afi-vrf nmaas enable|
router bgp4 65535| afi-vrf nmaas redistribute connected|
router bgp4 65535| afi-vrf nmaas redistribute static|
router bgp4 65535| !|
router bgp4 65535| !|
router bgp4 65535| redistribute connected route-policy prefer|
router bgp4 65535| redistribute static route-policy prefer|
router bgp4 65535| ecmp|
router bgp4 65535| exit|
|!|

noti#
noti#show running-config router bgp4 65535 | xml
info userReader.cmdEnter:userReader.java:1141 command noti#show running-config router 
bgp4 65535 | xml  from local:telnet <loop> 23 -> 127.0.0.1 41076
2023-03-02 13:50:11
<config><router><bgp4><identifier-value>identifier-escape&#54;5535

</identifier-value></bgp4></router>
<router><bgp4><identifier-value><vrf><inet>
</inet></vrf>
<local-as><identifier-value>identifier-escape&#54;5535

</identifier-value></local-as>
<router-id><identifier-value>identifier-escape&#49;0.10.10.11

</identifier-value></router-id>
<address-family><unicast><multicast><ouni><omlt><flowspec><oflw><vpnuni><vpnmlt><vpnflw><ovpnuni><ovpnmlt><ovpnflw><vpls><mspw><evpn><mdt><nsh><rpd><rtfilter><srte><osrt><linkstate><mvpn><omvpn>
</omvpn></mvpn></linkstate></osrt></srte></rtfilter></rpd></nsh></mdt></evpn></mspw></vpls></ovpnflw></ovpnmlt></ovpnuni></vpnflw></vpnmlt></vpnuni></oflw></flowspec></omlt></ouni></multicast></unicast></address-family>
<monitor><bmp><inet><identifier-value>identifier-escape&#49;0.10.10.10
<identifier-value>identifier-escape&#49;7971

</identifier-value></identifier-value></inet></bmp></monitor>
<template><r><remote-as><identifier-value>identifier-escape&#54;5535

</identifier-value></remote-as></r></template>
<template><r><local-as><identifier-value>identifier-escape&#54;5535

</identifier-value></local-as></r></template>
<template><r><address-family><unicast><multicast><ouni><omlt><flowspec><oflw><vpnuni><vpnmlt><vpnflw><ovpnuni><ovpnmlt><ovpnflw><vpls><mspw><evpn><mdt><nsh><rpd><rtfilter><srte><osrt><linkstate><mvpn><omvpn>
</omvpn></mvpn></linkstate></osrt></srte></rtfilter></rpd></nsh></mdt></evpn></mspw></vpls></ovpnflw></ovpnmlt></ovpnuni></vpnflw></vpnmlt></vpnuni></oflw></flowspec></omlt></ouni></multicast></unicast></address-family></r></template>
<template><r><distance><identifier-value>identifier-escape&#50;00

</identifier-value></distance></r></template>
<template><r><connection-mode><active>
</active></connection-mode></r></template>
<template><r><compression><both>
</both></compression></r></template>
<template><r><additional-path-rx><unicast><multicast><vpnuni><vpnmlt>
</vpnmlt></vpnuni></multicast></unicast></additional-path-rx></r></template>
<template><r><additional-path-tx><unicast><multicast><vpnuni><vpnmlt>
</vpnmlt></vpnuni></multicast></unicast></additional-path-tx></r></template>
<template><r><update-source><loopback0>
</loopback0></update-source></r></template>
<template><r><monitor><bmp>
</bmp></monitor></r></template>
<template><r><hostname><domain>
</domain></hostname></r></template>
<template><r><software>
</software></r></template>
<template><r><extended-open>
</extended-open></r></template>
<template><r><extended-update>
</extended-update></r></template>
<template><r><aigp>
</aigp></r></template>
<template><r><traffeng>
</traffeng></r></template>
<template><r><pmsitun>
</pmsitun></r></template>
<template><r><tunenc>
</tunenc></r></template>
<template><r><linkstate>
</linkstate></r></template>
<template><r><attribset>
</attribset></r></template>
<template><r><unknowns-out><all>
</all></unknowns-out></r></template>
<template><r><unknowns-in><all>
</all></unknowns-in></r></template>
<template><r><segrout>
</segrout></r></template>
<template><r><bier>
</bier></r></template>
<template><r><role><attrib>
</attrib></role></r></template>
<template><r><send-community><all>
</all></send-community></r></template>
<neighbor><identifier-value>identifier-escape&#49;0.5.1.10
<template><r>
</r></template></identifier-value></neighbor>
<neighbor><identifier-value>identifier-escape&#49;0.26.26.2
<template><r>
</r></template></identifier-value></neighbor>
<afi-vrf><nmaas><enable>
</enable></nmaas></afi-vrf>
<afi-vrf><nmaas><redistribute><connected>
</connected></redistribute></nmaas></afi-vrf>
<afi-vrf><nmaas><redistribute><static>
</static></redistribute></nmaas></afi-vrf>
<redistribute><connected><route-policy><prefer>
</prefer></route-policy></connected></redistribute>
<redistribute><static><route-policy><prefer>
</prefer></route-policy></static></redistribute>
<ecmp>
</ecmp>
</identifier-value></bgp4></router></config>

noti#



On 3/1/23 16:17, David Schmitz wrote:
> Hi,
>
> On Wed, 22 Feb 2023, mc36 wrote:
>
> > Date: Wed, 22 Feb 2023 09:05:25 +0100
> > From: mc36 <>
> > To: , David Schmitz <>
> > Subject: Re: [rare-dev] netconf
> >
> > hi,
> >
> > On 2/22/23 08:32, David Schmitz wrote:
> > > The "-" can also not be the first character of a XML element name.
> >
> > here we goo:
> >
> > https://github.com/rare-freertr/freeRtr/commit/16b65de6b33b29d732d2615cd0ddeec8cc247955
>
> Now, just after having accomplished a working test-wise BGP FlowSpec exchange between an extended version of test bed 
> https://github.com/rare-freertr/validated-design/tree/main/000-man/004a-run-bgp-rr
> and my own freertr router having a network connection to my test FoD,
> I continued to look at the XML NETCONF data.
>
> It still seems to have a strange bug:
>
> ...
>         </script>
>         <access-list>
>             <rule1 />
>         </access-list>
>         <access-list>
>             <rule1>
>                 <sequence>
>                     <identifier-value>identifier-escape10
>                     <permit>
>                         <identifier-value>identifier-escape58
>                         <any>
>                             <all>
>                                 <any>
>                                     <all />
>                                 </any>
>                             </all>
>                         </any></identifier-value>
>                     </permit></identifier-value>
>                 </sequence>
>             </rule1>
>             <rule10 />
>         </access-list>
>         <access-list>
>             <rule10>
>                 <sequence>
> ...
>
> This snippet is from own freertr router, with the the following access list 
> config:
>
> sh ru rule
> access-list rule1
>    sequence 10 permit 58 any all any all
>    exit
> access-list rule10
>    sequence 10 permit 58 any all any all
>    exit
> access-list rule20
>    sequence 10 deny 6 12.12.12.12 255.255.255.255 3 13.13.13.13 
> 255.255.255.255 13
>    exit
> access-list rule21
>    sequence 10 deny 6 any 789 any 0
>    exit
> access-list rule3
>    sequence 10 permit 58 any all any all
>    exit
> access-list rule5
>    sequence 10 permit 6 10.1.11.1 255.255.255.255 7-19 10.1.1.1 
> 255.255.255.255 33-78
>    exit
> access-list rule9
>    sequence 10 permit 1 any all any all
>    exit
>
>
> So, as you can see, there is defined in the config a single access list named 
> "rule1",
> but in the XML above
> the XML element
>         <access-list>
>             <rule1 />
>         </access-list>
> precedes
> the actual <access-list>
>                         <rule1 ...
> XML element.
>
> This seems to happen for all the access lists.
> And, it happens as well for policy-maps:
>
> ...
>             </asdf>
>             <policy-map-p4 />
>         </policy-map>
>         <policy-map>
>             <policy-map-p4>
>                 <sequence>
>                     <identifier-value>identifier-escape1
>                     <description /></identifier-value>
>                 </sequence>
>                 <sequence>
>                     <identifier-value>identifier-escape1
>                     <action>
>                         <drop />
> ...
>
>
> Best Regards
> David
>
> > br,
> > cs