Rare project developers

[mc36 <>]

hi,
nope, i went the 3rd way, as it gets set by default in the current p4src...
br,
cs


On 11/2/22 16:00, Fr  d  ric LOUI wrote:
> HI,
>
> Thanks for this confirmation.
> We reached the same observation with 9.7.2 and 9.10.0 (using NixPkgs binaries)
> Now we are in a situation where INTEL asked us to provide traces in a form of 
> ptf test.
>
> 1- with bf_router.p4 compiled for "tna" and compiled for TOFINO1 (use of 
> --arch=tf1)
> 2- with bf_router.p4 compiled for "tna" and compiled for TOFINO2 (use of 
> --arch=tf2)
> 3- with bf_router.p4 compiled with "t2na.p4" TNA and compiled for TOFINO2 
> (use of --arch=tf2)
>
> Did you try -2- ? According to Vladimir   s first answer, tna.p4 is a 
> portable network architecture and should result in the same behaviour on 
> TOFINO 1 and TOFINO 2 ?
>
> I tried myself -2- and the problem is consistent and persist.
>
> Frederic
>
> > Le 2 nov. 2022    12:20, mc36 <> a   crit :
> >
> > hi,
> > on tofino2 with sde910 i was able to start the minimal bf_router and found 
> > that
> > the constant table ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit get compiled badly... first thing to 
> > note
> > here is the functions all point to to_cpu and running the program through it 
> > does
> > not hit anything...
> > br,
> > cs
> >
> >
> > :11-02 07:17:20.021628:    :0x8:-:<0,0,->:------------ Stage 3 ------------
> > :11-02 07:17:20.022014:    :0x8:-:<0,0,3>:Ingress : Table 
> > ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit.tbl_pkt_pre_emit is miss
> > :11-02 07:17:20.022048:        :0x8:-:<0,0,3>:Key:
> > :11-02 07:17:20.022100:        :0x8:-:<0,0,3>: ig_md.mpls0_remove[0:0] = 0x0
> > :11-02 07:17:20.022123:        :0x8:-:<0,0,3>: ig_md.mpls1_remove[0:0] = 0x0
> > :11-02 07:17:20.022146:        :0x8:-:<0,0,3>: 
> > ig_md.mpls_encap_decap_sap_type[2:0] = 0x4
> > :11-02 07:17:20.022160:        :0x8:-:<0,0,3>: 
> > ig_md.mpls_encap_l2vpn_valid[0:0] = 0x0
> > :11-02 07:17:20.022174:        :0x8:-:<0,0,3>: 
> > ig_md.mpls_encap_l3vpn_valid[0:0] = 0x0
> > :11-02 07:17:20.022193:        :0x8:-:<0,0,3>: 
> > ig_md.mpls_encap_rawip_valid[0:0] = 0x0
> > :11-02 07:17:20.022208:        :0x8:-:<0,0,3>: ig_md.nexthop_id[15:0] = 0xB4A6
> > :11-02 07:17:20.022226:        :0x8:-:<0,0,3>: 
> > ig_md.srv_encap_l3vpn_valid[0:0] = 0x0
> > :11-02 07:17:20.022240:        :0x8:-:<0,0,3>: ig_md.srv_remove[0:0] = 0x0
> > :11-02 07:17:20.022257:        :0x8:-:<0,0,3>:Execute Default Action: NoAction
> > :11-02 07:17:20.022281:        :0x8:-:<0,0,3>:Action Results:
> > :11-02 07:17:20.022298:        :0x8:-:<0,0,3>:Next Table = --END_OF_PIPELINE--
> >
> >
> > bfrt.bf_router.pipe.ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit> dump
> > ----------------------------------------------> dump()
> > ----- tbl_pkt_pre_emit Dump Start -----
> > Default Entry:
> > Entry data (action : NoAction):
> >
> > Entry 0:
> > Entry key:
> >     ig_md.srv_encap_l3vpn_valid    : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_rawip_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l3vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l2vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.srv_remove               : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls0_remove             : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls1_remove             : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_decap_sap_type : 0x0
> >     ig_md.nexthop_id               : ('0x0002', '0xFFFF')
> >     $MATCH_PRIORITY                : 0
> > Entry data (action : ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit.act_pkt_send_to_cpu):
> >
> > Entry 1:
> > Entry key:
> >     ig_md.srv_encap_l3vpn_valid    : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_rawip_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l3vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l2vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.srv_remove               : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls0_remove             : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls1_remove             : 0x1
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_decap_sap_type : 0x0
> >     ig_md.nexthop_id               : ('0x0002', '0xFFFF')
> >     $MATCH_PRIORITY                : 1
> > Entry data (action : ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit.act_pkt_send_to_cpu):
> >
> > Entry 2:
> > Entry key:
> >     ig_md.srv_encap_l3vpn_valid    : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_rawip_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l3vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l2vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.srv_remove               : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls0_remove             : 0x1
> >     ig_md.mpls1_remove             : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_decap_sap_type : 0x0
> >     ig_md.nexthop_id               : ('0x0002', '0xFFFF')
> >     $MATCH_PRIORITY                : 2
> > Entry data (action : ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit.act_pkt_send_to_cpu):
> >
> > Entry 3:
> > Entry key:
> >     ig_md.srv_encap_l3vpn_valid    : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_rawip_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l3vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l2vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.srv_remove               : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls0_remove             : 0x1
> >     ig_md.mpls1_remove             : 0x1
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_decap_sap_type : 0x0
> >     ig_md.nexthop_id               : ('0x0002', '0xFFFF')
> >     $MATCH_PRIORITY                : 3
> > Entry data (action : ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit.act_pkt_send_to_cpu):
> >
> > Entry 4:
> > Entry key:
> >     ig_md.srv_encap_l3vpn_valid    : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_rawip_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l3vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l2vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.srv_remove               : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls0_remove             : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls1_remove             : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_decap_sap_type : 0x4
> >     ig_md.nexthop_id               : ('0x0002', '0xFFFF')
> >     $MATCH_PRIORITY                : 4
> > Entry data (action : ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit.act_pkt_send_to_cpu):
> >
> > Entry 5:
> > Entry key:
> >     ig_md.srv_encap_l3vpn_valid    : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_rawip_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l3vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l2vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.srv_remove               : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls0_remove             : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls1_remove             : 0x1
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_decap_sap_type : 0x4
> >     ig_md.nexthop_id               : ('0x0002', '0xFFFF')
> >     $MATCH_PRIORITY                : 5
> > Entry data (action : ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit.act_pkt_send_to_cpu):
> >
> > Entry 6:
> > Entry key:
> >     ig_md.srv_encap_l3vpn_valid    : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_rawip_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l3vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l2vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.srv_remove               : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls0_remove             : 0x1
> >     ig_md.mpls1_remove             : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_decap_sap_type : 0x4
> >     ig_md.nexthop_id               : ('0x0002', '0xFFFF')
> >     $MATCH_PRIORITY                : 6
> > Entry data (action : ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit.act_pkt_send_to_cpu):
> >
> > Entry 7:
> > Entry key:
> >     ig_md.srv_encap_l3vpn_valid    : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_rawip_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l3vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l2vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.srv_remove               : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls0_remove             : 0x1
> >     ig_md.mpls1_remove             : 0x1
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_decap_sap_type : 0x4
> >     ig_md.nexthop_id               : ('0x0002', '0xFFFF')
> >     $MATCH_PRIORITY                : 7
> > Entry data (action : ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit.act_pkt_send_to_cpu):
> >
> > Entry 8:
> > Entry key:
> >     ig_md.srv_encap_l3vpn_valid    : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_rawip_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l3vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l2vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.srv_remove               : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls0_remove             : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls1_remove             : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_decap_sap_type : 0x6
> >     ig_md.nexthop_id               : ('0x0002', '0xFFFF')
> >     $MATCH_PRIORITY                : 8
> > Entry data (action : ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit.act_pkt_send_to_cpu):
> >
> > Entry 9:
> > Entry key:
> >     ig_md.srv_encap_l3vpn_valid    : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_rawip_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l3vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l2vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.srv_remove               : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls0_remove             : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls1_remove             : 0x1
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_decap_sap_type : 0x6
> >     ig_md.nexthop_id               : ('0x0002', '0xFFFF')
> >     $MATCH_PRIORITY                : 9
> > Entry data (action : ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit.act_pkt_send_to_cpu):
> >
> > Entry 10:
> > Entry key:
> >     ig_md.srv_encap_l3vpn_valid    : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_rawip_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l3vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l2vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.srv_remove               : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls0_remove             : 0x1
> >     ig_md.mpls1_remove             : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_decap_sap_type : 0x6
> >     ig_md.nexthop_id               : ('0x0002', '0xFFFF')
> >     $MATCH_PRIORITY                : 10
> > Entry data (action : ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit.act_pkt_send_to_cpu):
> >
> > Entry 11:
> > Entry key:
> >     ig_md.srv_encap_l3vpn_valid    : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_rawip_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l3vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_l2vpn_valid   : 0x0
> >     ig_md.srv_remove               : 0x0
> >     ig_md.mpls0_remove             : 0x1
> >     ig_md.mpls1_remove             : 0x1
> >     ig_md.mpls_encap_decap_sap_type : 0x6
> >     ig_md.nexthop_id               : ('0x0002', '0xFFFF')
> >     $MATCH_PRIORITY                : 11
> > Entry data (action : ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit.act_pkt_send_to_cpu):
> >
> > ----- tbl_pkt_pre_emit Dump End -----
> >
> >
> > bfrt.bf_router.pipe.ig_ctl.ig_ctl_pkt_pre_emit>
> >
> >
> > On 11/2/22 11:33, mc36 wrote:
> > > hi,
> > > i tried to reproduce the tofino2 issue with the latest sde911 but i get the 
> > > below error...
> > > the forwarder errors out pointing to the sde itself... it works if i start 
> > > for tofino1...
> > > any idea on how to proceed?
> > > thanks,
> > > cs
> > > bf_forwarder.py running on: ACCTON_WEDGE100BF_32X
> > > Connected to control plane 10.10.10.227:9080
> > > GRPC_ADDRESS: 127.0.0.1:50052
> > > P4_NAME: bf_router
> > > CLIENT_ID: 0
> > > Subscribe attempt #1
> > > Subscribe response received 0
> > > Connected to grcp server
> > > Traceback (most recent call last):
> > >     File 
> > > "/home/mc36/bf-sde-9.11.0/install/lib/python3.9/site-packages/tofino/bfrt_grpc/client.py",
> > >  line 494, in bfrt_info_get
> > >         msg = self.stub.GetForwardingPipelineConfig(req)
> > >     File "/usr/lib/python3/dist-packages/grpc/_channel.py", line 826, in 
> > > __call__
> > >         return _end_unary_response_blocking(state, call, False, None)
> > >     File "/usr/lib/python3/dist-packages/grpc/_channel.py", line 729, in 
> > > _end_unary_response_blocking
> > >         raise _InactiveRpcError(state)
> > > grpc._channel._InactiveRpcError: <_InactiveRpcError of RPC that terminated 
> > > with:
> > >          status = StatusCode.UNKNOWN
> > >          details = "Unexpected error in RPC handling"
> > >          debug_error_string = "{"created","description":"Error received from peer 
> > > ipv4:127.0.0.1:50052","file":"src/core/lib/surface/call.cc","file_line":1055,"grpc_message":"Unexpected error in RPC 
> > > handling","grpc_status":2}"
> > > >
> > > During handling of the above exception, another exception occurred:
> > > Traceback (most recent call last):
> > >     File "/home/mc36/rare/bfrt_python/bf_forwarder.py", line 100, in <module>
> > >         bf_client, bf_client_id = newClient(bind = True)
> > >     File "/home/mc36/rare/bfrt_python/bf_forwarder.py", line 85, in newClient
> > >         client = BfRuntimeGrpcClient(
> > >     File "/home/mc36/rare/bfrt_python/rare/bf_grpc_client/__init__.py", line 
> > > 40, in __init__
> > >         self.bfrt_info = self.interface.bfrt_info_get()
> > >     File 
> > > "/home/mc36/bf-sde-9.11.0/install/lib/python3.9/site-packages/tofino/bfrt_grpc/client.py",
> > >  line 496, in bfrt_info_get
> > >         raise BfruntimeForwardingRpcException(e)
> > >     File 
> > > "/home/mc36/bf-sde-9.11.0/install/lib/python3.9/site-packages/tofino/bfrt_grpc/client.py",
> > >  line 266, in __init__
> > >         assert(grpc_error.code() != grpc.StatusCode.UNKNOWN)
> > > AssertionError