An open discussion list for topics related to the eduGAIN interfederation service.

[Barbara Monticini <barbara.monticini AT garr.it>]

Il 23/10/2018 10:51, Andi Malaj ha scritto:
> Hello,
>
> Thanks for all points notified.We will correct them ASAP.
> Apologies for the mess about the name. We started calling it 'eduGAIN 
> Albania', then we passed in 'eduID Albania' to be aligned with other 
> federations.
> We are updating all documentation.
>
> Thanks

Hi Andi,

please consider also my points. Some are already covered by Rhys comments.

Hope to be of any help.

Regards
Barbara


********************************************************************
Document: https://eduid.rash.al/wp-content/uploads/MRPS-20180926.pdf
********************************************************************

Title: Federation Operator Practice: Metadata Registration Practice 
Statement


3. Member Eligibility and Ownership

The procedure for becoming a member of the Federation is documented at:
https://edugain.rash.al

- the site does not exist!

4. Metadata Format

The MRPS SHALL be published on the IRFED federation web site at the 
following
URL:
https://eduid.rash.al/documents/MRPS-20180926.pdf

- IRFED to be corrected

- the link returns "Nothing found, Are you lost? Try another search 
below or click one of the latest posts."


5.1 EntityID Format

The process by which a Federation member can register an entity is 
described at:
https://edugain.rash.al/documents/

- the site does not exist!


5.2 EntityID Format

- same title of 5.1

********************************************************************
Document: 
https://eduid.rash.al/wp-content/uploads/edugain-Federation-Policy.pdf
********************************************************************

Title: Identity Federation Policy


3.3 Obligations and Rights of Federation Members


In addition to what is stated elsewhere in the Federation Policy all 
Federation Members:
...
• Must pay the fees. Prices and payment terms are specified in appendix 
Fees.

- the document contains no appendices


4. Eligibility
....
4.1 Rules of membership

- is it applies to Institutions of the higher education outside Albania? 
Institutions of secondary education outside Albania?
- can a Partner run a Home Org?

5. Procedures
5.1 How to join

The Federation Operator presents a recommendation for membership with an 
evaluation report to the Members’ Board who in turn decides on whether 
to grant or deny the application.

- what about the first applicant if there is no MB?



General suggestion: Federation entities and Federation metadata

- I would suggest to create a first Entity (test SP operated by eduID AL 
Federation) in order to produce the first Federation metadata and to 
facilitate idps set up in the Federation.


--
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Barbara Monticini         GARR-CERT             Tel: +39 0554572681
V. Bruno Rossi ang. V.le delle Idee          50019 Sesto Fiorentino
c/o Dip. Fisica Sperimentale               primo piano - stanza 113
PGP key:   http://www.cert.garr.it/servizi/informazioni-su-pgp-keys
-------------------------------------------------------------------

Attachment: smime.p7s
Description: Firma crittografica S/MIME